PACTAby Fractal Neurons
Request a dossier

Protocol scorecards

Docs vs chain, a five-factor control-plane rosette and the main difference for each of 90 protocols. Select a row for the evidence.

Aligned means the docs are accurate, not that the protocol is low-risk.

Docs vs chain compares what a protocol publishes with what its contracts enforce at a finalized block. The rosette shows how strong the controls themselves are.

RosetteStrongModerateWeakNot determinedLonger, greener slices are stronger. Clockwise from the top: upgradeability, timelock floor, signer quorum, emergency scope, docs-vs-chain parity.

Protocol scorecards: docs-vs-chain status, five-factor control-plane rosette and the main difference for each protocol. Select a row to expand its evidence.
ProtocolDocs vs chainControl-plane rosetteWhat differsExpand
BaseAlignedPause and unpause admin is the Aave Guardian 4-of-7 Safe, as documented
EthereumAlignedACL admin role, executor delay and Guardian Safe match the docs
EthereumAlignedOnly allow-listed proposers can submit root bundles, as documented
BaseDeltaVoter emergency council and epoch governor are the AerodromeMigration contract
BaseAlignedPool factory owner and fee managers are the 3-of-7 team Safe, as documented
EthereumDeltaDeployment config lists an older gateway implementation; 3-day timelock with operator path
EthereumAlignedAuthorizer admin role is the 6-of-11 DAO multisig, as documented
EthereumDeltaDocs list an older restaking implementation; uniETH upgrades via a 3-of-5 Safe ProxyAdmin
BaseDeltaTimelock delay: docs 6 hours · chain none
EthereumProtectiveAccess-control admin is a Timelock, not the multisig the docs name
BaseAlignedOpsGuardian has no pause authority over Root, as documented
EthereumDeltaDocs: only the MCMS proposes · chain: a 6-of-12 Safe can also propose
Base · EthereumAlignedUSDC roles on Base are single admin addresses, as Circle documents
EthereumAlignedThe exchange rate is set by a rate-limited updater, as documented
BaseAlignedBase markets follow the Ethereum Timelock plus a 1-day local timelock
EthereumAlignedGovernor, 48-hour Timelock and Pause Guardian Safe match the docs
EthereumDeltaVault and factory manager Safe runs at 1-of-2 despite documented role separation
EthereumAlignedBooster governance ownership chain matches the docs
EthereumDeltacrvUSD factory admin is a LendingOwnerProxy; docs name the OwnershipAgent
EthereumAlignedCore ProxyAdmin, executor Safe and 10-day Timelock match the docs
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 7 days (stricter)
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 7 days · chain 1 day
EthereumProtectiveUSDtb PSM is owned by a 24-hour timelock, not the Dev multisig directly
EthereumProtective10-day upgrade timelock; a queued LayerZero delegate change moves behind it
EthereumAlignedRolesAuthority owner and timelock wiring match the docs
EthereumAlignedFactory upgrades wait 4 days in a timelock (DAO 4-of-8 proposes), as documented
BaseObservedNon-proxy lending pool with role-based admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaTreasury admin sits with the Ops and Emergency Safes, not the 3-day Timelock
EthereumAlignedsUSDf cooldown is zero, so unstaking to USDf is instant, as documented
EthereumDeltaMigration auth is live on four vaults, beyond the documented multisig scope
EthereumAlignedfrxETHMinter owner is the documented Comptroller
EthereumAlignedUpgrades go through a 1-day timelock run by the 4-of-7 Frax Safe
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 2 days · chain 36 hours
EthereumAlignedAllocator custody role admin is the Grove SubProxy under Sky governance
EthereumDeltaPause roles are administered by MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER; docs say GOVERNOR
EthereumDeltaPolicy Committee Safe: docs 5-of-9 · chain 4-of-7
EthereumAlignedProxyAdmin sits behind a 10-day timelock; config admin Safe as documented
EthereumAlignedEndpoint is immutable; a 5-of-9 multisig sets the message defaults, as documented
EthereumAlignedDual Governance timelock delays and committee Safes match the docs
EthereumAlignedUpgrade and admin firewalls are run by 4-of-7 Safes, as documented
EthereumAlignedLiquidation thresholds are 110% and 150% in Recovery Mode, as documented
EthereumAlignedSampled owner and proxy slots match the docs
EthereumAlignedCore ProxyAdmin wiring and 24-hour timelock match the docs
EthereumAlignedMToken has no proxy slots: immutable core logic, as documented
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 3 days (stricter)
EthereumDeltaProxy admin is the 4-of-7 DAO Safe; docs describe a 3-day GovernorTimelock
EthereumDeltaCurator Safe: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-5
EthereumDeltaRe7 WETH vault has no guardian; its owner is a 2-of-4 Safe with a 3-day timelock
BaseDeltaPause guardian: docs 3-of-5 Security Council · chain 2-of-4 Safe
EthereumAlignedSingleton owner and fee and LLTV bounds match the docs
EthereumAlignedGovernance needs 3 Advisory Board votes plus a 24-hour timelock, as documented
EthereumDeltaSupply: docs cap 500M · chain no cap; a 2-of-3 Safe holds the minter role
EthereumDeltaOUSG instant mint limit: docs $50M · chain $100M per day
BaseObservedVault proxy admin path runs through a 2-day timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedPause and asset-protection roles sit with one key address, as documented
EthereumAlignedMarkets send 80% of swap fees to the treasury and 20% to LPs, as documented
EthereumDeltaCommunity multisig: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-7
EthereumAligned0.25% shield fees; upgrades and pauses only via the on-chain protocol vote, as documented
EthereumProtectiveVault admin role sits only behind the timelock; docs say the Safe holds it too
EthereumDeltaRestaking fee: docs 10% · chain 15%
EthereumAlignedLong freeze is 1 week, the documented default
EthereumAlignedUSR admin-rules delay and request counters match the docs
EthereumDeltaSafe threshold: docs 3-of-4 · chain 3-of-5
EthereumDeltaCouncil leave notice: chain 28 days · RPIP-33 bound under 14 days
EthereumAlignedv1.4.1 singleton and factory code match Safe's registry; singletons cannot be initialized
BaseObservedNon-proxy address provider with role-based admin; docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveBeacon upgrades already wait 3 days in a timelock the docs say will be added
EthereumAlignedAddresses provider owner and governance delay match the docs
EthereumAlignedSSVNetwork owner is the DAO governance multisig, as documented
EthereumDeltaManager Safe: docs 3-of-5 · chain 3-of-6
EthereumDeltaTimelock: docs 2 days · chain 5 days; Treasury Safe 3-of-5, not 4-of-7
EthereumAlignedGovernance timelock delay is 48 hours, as documented
EthereumAlignedKeeper oracle quorum, osETH fee and LTV settings match the docs
EthereumAlignedPools and treasurer are owned by a 5-of-7 multisig, as documented
EthereumAlignedsteakUSDC guardian is its own Aragon DAO, as announced
BaseAlignedMetaMorpho vault timelock is 7 days, as documented
BaseObservedSuperGovernor and vault aggregator control plane pinned; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedUSDC subscription fee and fund supply match the docs
EthereumAligned7-day SwellTimelock, ProxyAdmins and reprice bounds match the docs
EthereumAlignedCore registries are non-upgradeable; factory Safes match the docs
EthereumAlignedAccount NFT is owned by the CoreProxy, not a key or Safe, as documented
EthereumAlignedOwner is a 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet, as documented
EthereumAlignedtBTC timelock is 1 day; the WalletRegistry upgrade schedule is public
EthereumAlignedTREE owner is a 5-day timelock; a blacklistable upgrade is queued
EthereumDeltaVoting period: docs 7 days · chain 5.6 days
Base · EthereumAlignedOwner is the 2-day governance Timelock run by GovernorBravo, as documented
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 3 days · chain 1 second
Base · EthereumAlignedMessages and upgrades need 13 of 19 guardians on Ethereum and Base, as documented
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 7 days (stricter)
BaseDeltaTimelock delay: docs 2 days · chain none